data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e0e31/e0e3116ca16f8803bddf3dc753d516650b47aa22" alt=""
Release Date: November 6, 2012
Age Group: YA
Source: Review copy from publisher
Reviewed By: Madi B
Review:
After I read Tin Star I was thinking “Aliens? Space? Planets? OH HECK YES!” My compassion really went out for this book mainly because of the cover. My dad was saying they drew a circle on the cover therefore they’re trying to get people to associate the book with The Hunger Games. So my compassion went out for this book and I defended it! (You should have seen my dad when he found out her name is Katya) I felt bad for this book whose cover looked like a bad 80’s video game. (I’m not ALL 80’s video games are bad, just some of them)
My attitude for the book started out “YEAH!!!” and just went downhill from there. I DIDN’T EVEN FINISH THE BOOK!!!! Now with me, that rarely happens. I’m normally a book-finisher not a book-put-er-down-er. This may be a side effect of by previous lack of books, but nevertheless it’s there! I tried hard to finish this one (I did defend it like I would The Fault in Our Stars) but I JUST COULDN’T HANDLE IT!
The first thing I didn’t love was Katya. She was kinda hard-core I guess but I didn’t CONNECT with her. (frowny-face) I really didn’t like the setting either. It was cold and detached. To me, that’s what the tone of the book was, cold and detached. I also didn’t like all the talk about submarines. Now, I’d be fine with just talking about riding in a submarine. But talking about EVERY SINGLE PART of the submarine. UHHHH NO! And the author used all these mechanical terms like I knew what they were, which would be ok but… NO ONE KNOWS WHAT A HALOCLINE IS! Or a rusocline! Or a Judas Box, Sonar returns, or a pycnoline! GAHHHH!
And are you ready for the WORST TRAGEDY OF ALL? NO ROMANCE!!! Not even the a glimmer of a HOPE of any romantic anything!!!! ULTRA GAHHHHHH!!!! But I when I went on Amazon reviews to see if everyone else hated this book, I saw...some people actually liked it. LIKE FOR REAL! Am I crazy? Do I belong in the nuthouse??? I tried so hard to like this book, but to no avail.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Word verification stinks--- but spammers are worse. Thank you for your patience!